20 Nov They’ll Never Replace Us.
by Roxanne D. Brown
Tens of thousands of airline passengers continued threading their way across U.S. airspace last week after an equipment failure knocked out radar and communications networks, throwing the nation’s aviation system into chaos.
Pilots, flight attendants, air-traffic controllers and ground crews worked in perfect tandem—over several stressful hours—to land the 4,000 or so planes caught in midair when the crisis erupted.
These workers, many of them members of unions, turned to backup systems, simple text messages and seat-of-the-pants ingenuity to bring everyone down safely. It was their skill, their aplomb under pressure, that saved the day.
It’s a poignant reminder that no matter how much corporations try to dehumanize the workplace and elbow us aside, it’s always going to be working people who make the difference.

Growing numbers of Americans fear that AI will eliminate or gut their jobs, leaving them penniless and rudderless in a kind of zombie economy. They worry that AI will obliterate our sense of community and cut the other cords binding us to one another, on and off the job.
Little wonder they feel that way.
Corporations brag about their efforts to replace people with AI and robots. Even tech workers find themselves in the crosshairs, with companies like Amazon, Meta and Microsoft gleefully kicking out the coders and developers who catapulted them to prosperity in the first place.
Some of the world’s richest people, always hungry for more of everything, envision factories operated by robots instead of people. It might be cheaper for them. But it wouldn’t be better for anyone.
No robot will ever make steel for bridges, tires for cars or aluminum for planes with the care that members of the United Steelworkers (USW) do.
After all, we drive across those bridges. Our kids ride to school on those tires. Our families fly in those planes.
In a health care industry increasingly dominated by hedge funds and other faceless behemoths, some hospitals and nursing homes trot out robots as caregivers. But no bloodless machine will ever offer a compassionate touch to the dying, reassure a frightened patient or advocate for better care the way USW members in the health professions do every day.
No technology will ever deliver a greater dividend than union solidarity, which lifts everyone to greater heights and harnesses collective power for smarter, more productive workplaces.
And let me tell you, AI will never think outside the box as pilots and air-traffic controllers did last week and as other union workers have done time and again to solve a problem, meet a need or save a life.
It’s no coincidence that public support for unions continues to grow at the same time that the rich scheme to replace us.
Unions enable workers to come together to fight for fair treatment and job security.
We bargain contracts that welcome technology and even require employers to make the capital investments needed to keep our industries competitive.
But we force employers to treat AI and robots as tools—there to help workers perform their jobs more safely and efficiently. We insist that employers provide the training needed for workers to leverage new technology, grow in knowledge, and make greater contributions on the shop floor.
Polls show this is exactly what Americans want from AI.
Equipment breaks down, just as the aviation crisis showed, but working people always step up and get the job done.
We will always be the economy’s greatest asset. There’s simply no replacing us.